Wednesday, July 30, 2025

d100 Crimes you May Have Committed

This list is intended to replace Occupations in a 0-level DCC funnel involving a prison break, but who knows, it might have other uses too. The "Confiscated Evidence" column replaces trade goods and can be retrieved during the escape. Your trained weapon may also be retrieved.

It is up to you whether your character is guilty, justified, or has simply been framed.

d%CrimeTrained WeaponConfiscated Evidence
1Abandonment of PostLongswordInsignia
2Adulteration of GoodsRolling pin (as club)Sack of starch
3Armed RobberyLongswordBalaclava mask
4ArsonFirewood (as club)Flint-lighter
5AssassinationDaggerPhial of random poison
6Assault (Armed)Knife (as dagger)Coinpurse of 1d12 cp
7Assault (Magical)StaffBlack Grimoire
8Assault (Unarmed)Drawstring (as garrote)Sack
9Attempted MurderHatchetShovel
10BanditryShortswordRope (100')
11BeggingStick (as club)Beggar's bowl
12BrandishingLongswordBuckler
13BriberyBlackjack1d12 sp
14BlasphemyStaffHoly symbol
15Breaking and EnteringHammerCrowbar
16BurglaryDaggerLockpicks
17CoercionBlackjackQuality cloak
18CounterfeitingDagger1d20 counterfeit gp
19Cursing (Magical)StaffHex doll
20Cursing (Obscenity)SlingTablet with offensive carvings
21Dangerous Use of MagicStaffBurnt hair
22Deception by MagicStaffPhial of weird fluid
23Demonic BargainingDaggerDemonic symbol
24Desecration of a Holy SiteStick (as club)Sack of nightsoil
25DesertionSpearHide armor
26Destruction of CropsPitchfork (as spear)Flask of oil
27DissidenceQuill pen (as dart)Parchment and ink
28Disturbing the PeaceCudgel (as staff)Sack of potatoes
29DrunkennessTankard (as club)Keg of ale (half-empty)
30EmbezzlementQuill pen (as dart)Coffer (emptied)
31Excessive NoiseClubHorn
32ExtortionBlackjackSilver band (10 sp)
33False ConfessionClubIncriminating note, signed by you
34Fencing of Stolen GoodsDaggerGems worth 2d10 sp
35FraudQuill pen (as dart)Falsified document
36ForgeryQuill pen (as dart)Falsified wax stamp
37Game FixingBlackjackLoaded dice
38GossipKnife (as dagger)Slanderous letter
39Grand LarcenyShortswordWagon of stolen goods
40Grand Theft EquineStaffBridle
41GraverobbingShovel (as staff)Trowel
42Harbouring a FugitiveShortsword1 fugitive (additional 0-level PC)
43HoardingPitchfork (as spear)1 month's rations
44HorseplayClubPigskin ball
45ImitationHammerLow-quality copper ingots
46Impersonation (Animal)Skinner (as dagger)Horse hide
47Impersonation (Clergy)Scepter (as mace)Cassock
48Impersonation (Guard)LongswordCrested heater shield
49Impersonation (Nobility)DaggerSignet ring
50Inciting RebellionLongswordFacepaint
51Inciting FearWood stake (as dagger)Garlic
52Inciting ViolenceProtest sign (as club)1d12 rotten tomatoes
53InsubordinationSpearBrigandine armor
54Interfering with FeyTrowel (as dagger)Suspicious mushrooms
55KidnappingBlackjackSack with drawstring
56Loiteringnonenone
57Mind-Altering MagicksStirrer (as club)Pouch of magical herbs
58MuggingKnife (as dagger)Fistwraps
59MurderHatchetShovel
60Murder-by-ProxyStaffPhial of poison
61NecromancyDagger1d12 human bones
62Obstruction of JusticeShortswordMysterious locked chest
63PerjuryGavel (as hammer)Roll again for a different crime
64Petty TheftClub1d4 cp
65PickpocketingDaggerCoinpurse (1d20 cp)
66PiracyCutlass (as shortsword)1 pirated RPG book
67Public NudityClubFine suit of clothes
68PoachingShortbowDeerhide
69PossessionStaffCrystal ball (10sp)
70Prison-breakShiv (as dagger)Sheets tied together (50')
71Property DamageHammerBroken cart
72RacketeeringBlackjackShards of a broken window
73Resisting ArrestClubManacles
74Reckless Discharge of a MissileShortbowApple with an arrow in it
75RiotPitchfork (as spear)Torch
76Robbery of the TreasuryDaggerMarked banknotes
77RustlingCrook (as staff)1d3 sheep
78SlanderQuill pen (as dart)Roll of newspapers
79SmugglingLongswordIllicit "salts"
80SolicitingDaggerSexy chainmail (as chainmail)
81SwindlingLongswordSnake oil
82SquattingPlank (as club)Bedroll
83Tax EvasionDaggerGolden ingot
84TheftDaggerLoaf of bread
85TortureHammerPliers
86TreasonLongswordCake
87TrespassHatchetTent
88Unlawful PatronageStaffGoat marked for sacrifice
89Unlawful WorshipDaggerIllegal holy symbol
90Unsanctioned DuelingLongswordExpensive gloves (5 gp)
91Unsanctioned use of MagicStaffPile of ashes
92UsuryCudgel (as staff)Jewelry worth 10gp
93VagrancyStaffBindle
94WitchcraftBroom (as staff)Black cat
95Wrongful ImprisonmentClubChain (10')
96Wrongly Accused of [re-roll]Take re-roll resultTake re-roll result
97“Wrongly” Accused of [re-roll]*Take re-roll resultTake re-roll result
98[re-roll] and [roll again]Take both resultsTake both results
99Conspiracy to [re-roll]Take re-roll resultTake re-roll result
100Serial [re-roll]Take re-roll result2d4 times re-roll result
*this result doesn't make you guilty, but absolutely nobody believes you

Note: Some crimes have been intentionally omitted from this list due to their particularly sensitive nature. Some heinous acts would make it very difficult to play a likeable character. Additionally, some players may feel uncomfortable playing in a game where certain freedoms are considered a crime (even if such a thing might be historically realistic). The judge may adjust the list but is encouraged to know their audience and treat serious topics with due respect.

Wednesday, July 23, 2025

The Great Divide - Splitting Race and Class

There have been a lot of attempts at converting DCC's race-as-class into race-and-class. Now, I am an enthusiastic proponent of race-as-class. If you're reading this in the first place, it's probably not a hard sell for you. It makes non-human races special and it makes humans special too because they're the ones that can specialize. The hacks and homebrews I have been able to find for DCC fall short of this, instead ending up more like the race-and-class we see in modern RPGs, pejoratively referred to as "humans with masks". This is an attempt at splitting race and class, while maintaining the best part of DCC's races-as-classes.

∗ ∗ ∗

Skip to the rules.

∗ ∗ ∗

Design Points

  1. Avoid synergy yet recognize that by giving players options it can't be entirely eliminated.
  2. Encourage races to play differently as classes do by giving tools instead of bonuses.
  3. Make race significant, so that a demi-human Warrior (for instance) feels different to a human Warrior.
  4. Tie racial abilities to culture, such that it is impossible for a character's species to not affect their characterisation.

Points 1 and 2 are related, and points 2, 3 and 4 are all related.

Identifying the problem

A small bonus here and there is a quick and easy solution if you already like the way That Popular Fantasy Game handles it but - as you may have guessed - I don't. Distributing Ability Score bonuses across races immediately encourages minmaxing, because why wouldn't you pick the race with a bonus to your primary stat if you know what class you're playing? And if you don't yet know what class you're playing, why wouldn't you pick one that suits your race?

But that's only the start of it. "Humans with masks" comes from the fact that none of this encourages you to play - much less roleplay - in particular way based on your race. There's nothing to make an elf feel elfy. You don't end up with an interesting character because of their race in contrast to the rest of the party, you get a Barbarian like any other except "oh I'm a Goliath by the way". Someone encountering your character might not care or literally even notice, because you're travelling alongside a gnome, a kenku, some sort of robot, and a partridge in a pear tree - all of whom are just regular guys like yourself. What does being a Goliath do for your character? It makes him a better Barbarian, that's about it. At least, that's the only part we pay attention to.

Is it crazy to think that your species - quite literally what you are - should have a bigger impact on your life, character, and capabilities than a +2 and darkvision? I happen to think that my pets being a cat and a rabbit notably distinguishes them from the other members of my household, and this would hold true if they spoke Common and wielded a pitchfork (as spear) like the rest of us mortals.

My cat and rabbit are a Neutral Thief and Chaotic Wizard respectively.

Race-as-class

These issues are more or less addressed by race-as-class systems. A Halfling is now totally different from a human, no matter what class the human chooses. They may on the surface be similar to Thieves, but they have different scope, flavour and mechanics. Their abilities inform playstyle, but also character. Elves take a little more work to reach this point (the book doesn’t spell it out but leaning into Patrons and a long lifespan helps) and I wouldn't be the only one to say Dwarves are lacking (I like to add dwarfy rune magicks), but the general approach works. Give them their own entire class, and race is now as important as class.

However, even after having been converted to the old-school ways of race-as-class, I still can't help but feel it's kind of... clunky? Over-gamified? Unintuitive? It's hard to pin down. I still have somewhat of an involuntary visceral reaction to the suggestion of race-as-class, even with it being one of the reasons DCC is my system of choice. Despite my trepidations it seems to produce what we want it to at the table.

It feels, intuitively, like race and class shouldn't be the same category. They aren't the same kind of thing. If you're to think of it in wargaming terms however, each class (or race) is a certain kind of unit that can do certain things. It makes a bit more sense from this perspective, and it helps to explain why races become distinct when they are also a separate class. Perhaps it's the clash between Class as a game mechanic and Race as a character trait (in the narrative sense) that doesn't sit right with me. When answering "Class" with "Halfling" it sounds like a category error. It wouldn't if you asked for a "unit type" instead, but class and race are more than that. They serve roleplaying purposes, not just tactical gaming purposes.

As a final point (though maybe the weakest) having the ability to combine races and classes opens up more variety in player choices. I think this holds true even with demihumans being rare and randomly selected, since now the Elf player has a choice about what kind of Elf. In fact, this might be the simple answer to minmaxing, since Elves are already considered by some to be "Wizards but better" and it isn't generally a problem for DCC. You don't simply get to choose an Elf over a Wizard.

I still want to try to avoid obvious optimizations though, because if all Elves are going to be Wizards this entire exercise is pointless.

How else to do it?

If treating race as class is what makes race equally important to class, how can we achieve that while splitting them?

Multi-classing. Well, not exactly. Half-classes, or something like it. These multi-classing rules already achieve the possibility of combining a race and a class, albeit in a bit of a messy way where the character levels up their race separately from their class and gets a boatload of abilities because DCC's classes are all loaded with stuff. I still think these multi-classing rules are very good, it's just a bit strange for the same nebulous reason race-as-class feels strange.

When splitting race and class, I would make each race essentially the same thing as a class, but now you pick one of each. Races are given abilities much like class abilities; the kinds of things that define gameplay and provide options, not just +2 Strength and sniffing out gold.

If we instead gave each class only their defining abilities, and each race some abilities as a class, the player could now combine both without being too overloaded. For instance, a Halfling Warrior might gain both Mighty Deeds and Good Luck Charm, and both of those level up as the character does. Interestingly, this has the potential for anti-synergy where you don't want to choose a Dwarven Warrior, Elven Wizard, or Halfling Thief because you already have some of the abilities of the class - as such, it'll be necessary to pick and choose which abilities each class and race retains so that there isn't any blatant redundancy.

Hit Dice would be determined by the class but have the potential to be modified by the race. This threatens to become synergistic, so I'd limit it to one step up or down the dice chain. I don't think that can be particularly game-breaking. Alternatively, one could alternate between using the Class Hit Die or the Race Hit Die each level. That actually sounds better.

Action Dice, Crit Tables and Saves will receive similar treatment, probably just coming straight from the Class.

Luck Bonus is an interesting problem - I want to keep it for both races and classes because it can provide some nice flavour. Perhaps the player can pick from either the race's bonus or the class's bonus, although I have said before how odd I find that sort of design.

Then we have the classic problem of humans. What makes them so special? Being able to choose any class is no longer a human trait, but I want to lean into that affinity for specialization. I can think of two options. Each class could have one extra ability that is only granted to a human, making humans the best at each class while demihumans get their own unique niches on the side. 

Come to think of it, Luck Bonus could be a strictly human ability and depend on the class chosen, thus functioning as the human's ability to specialize. This feels dangerously like giving +2 to an ability score of the player's choice but it also makes humans feel like the chosen race of the Gods if you subscribe to that interpretation of Luck. It also lends well to the "new kids on the block" interpretation of humans by showing how they outcompete the other races while still being the normal, plain, generic race.

But having different stats makes sense!

You're right! I agree. I think we can do it while retaining the randomness and without introducing (much) race-class synergy. Instead of having a bonus, races will each get one stat they get to re-roll and take the higher of the two results. This keeps the same possible range and maintains a bell curve but pushes the curve ahead such that there are slightly more 18's and way less 3's, with only a slightly higher average.

Humans, being special of course, get to choose which stat they re-roll at level 1 instead of having it predetermined at level 0. This assists with the specialization motif. Humans don't all excel in one area, but they can excel in anything. They only get one chance at the re-roll though, and don't get to change their Class choice if their stats don't turn out as nicely as they wanted.

∗ ∗ ∗

Split Race and Class for DCC

Races

Race is determined randomly at character creation, as per the DCC core rules. Each race gets the listed abilities below, and one Ability Score which they re-roll and take the better result.

Human

Ability Score re-roll: Chosen by player at level 1 after deciding Class.

Humans add their Luck modifier to:

  • Their Turn Unholy checks as a Cleric
  • A favoured Thief Skill as a Thief (chosen at level 1)
  • A favoured Weapon as a Warrior (chosen at level 1)
  • Corruption and Mercurial Magic rolls as a Wizard.

Note that by implication other races do not get these Luck modifiers.

Hit Dice: Humans have the Hit Die granted by their chosen Class.

Dwarf

Ability Score re-roll: Stamina

Underground skills, Runetracing Deeds*, Shield Bash, Infravision

*Seen in Goodman Games Yearbook 8 and Gongfarmer's Almanac 2021 Vol. 7 but you can easily make your own. Just let a dwarf character learn rune words and make up magical Deed-ish effects for them. You're already adjudicating regular Mighty Deeds, you can handle this too.

Elf

Ability Score re-roll: Intelligence

Patron Bond and Invoke Patron at level 1 (cast these as Wizard, regardless of class), allergic to iron, access to one set of mithril gear at price of iron, Infravision, Heightened Senses

Halfling

Ability Score re-roll: Luck

Two-weapon Fighting, Good Luck Charm, Infravision

Classes

Class is chosen at level 1, with the only real difference being that all races can choose a class. They get the listed abilities below along with all of their racial abilities.

Cleric

Cleric casting and spells, Lay on Hands, Divine Aid

Thief

Thief Skill bonuses, Luck and Wits

Warrior

Mighty Deeds, Critical Threat Range, +CL to Initiative

Wizard

Wizard casting and spells, Spellburn, Languages

For all Races and Classes

Hit Dice

Odd levels use Class Hit Dice, even levels use Race Hit Dice.

Attack Bonus, Action Dice, Crit Table, Saving Throws

As per table for Class (not Race).

Stacking Abilities

As a general rule, abilities that do the same thing do not stack but you get the better of the two. Halfling Thieves regenerate 1 Luck per level, not 2. If a Deed Die rolls lower than your Attack Bonus, you get your Attack Bonus as the better result. If a Halfling Thief rolls a 1 on a Luck Die, they get 2 as a Halfling instead of 1 as a Thief.

∗ ∗ ∗

I don't consider this to be entirely complete or polished - I will definitely have to revisit it at some point - but I think it's playable. I've had less time to sit down and get into the nitty-gritty of this stuff lately (why did nobody tell me having a baby would be time-consuming?). At the very least, I hope this provides a framework for allowing any choice of race/class combination without losing the uniqueness that race-as-class systems provide. Ideally, demihumans should still feel special and unique, and there should still be a reason to be a human too. So let each of those keep what makes them unique.

Wednesday, July 16, 2025

6 Kinds of Dark

I recently came across this post about a dark entity on Goblin Punch and the post that inspired it on False Machine. I think they're brilliant. The idea of the darkness itself as a living, breathing, existential threat is a compelling one, and the idea that there are different species of it that I can catalogue for myself while my players might not even figure out they are two different things gives me a unique kind of joy.

The False Machine descriptions are evocative and inspiring, but emotion and metaphor doesn't leave much to actually use at the table. Its descriptions of darkness are often vague and amorphous as shadows themselves. I don't know how to present my players an encounter with a "contemptible dark" or one that "appreciates glass".

The Goblin Punch rules are generally quite good for darkness as a monster - dark must surround a light source before snuffing it and takes at least one Round per light source to do so (more for larger sources like campfires).  Fires aren't extinguished, just darkened. Lights can be "healed" by another light. Being swallowed by the dark deals damage per Round and escalating odds of random table effects occurring.

So here's a bunch of darks that look, feel, and smell different. Any of them can be:

  • A monster you can't stab
  • A puzzle in a room
  • Just how the shadows work in this dungeon, nobody knows why
  • What exists below the Underearth, the fragile foundation on which The Mundane World rests
  • A spell for a particularly edgy caster
Hey...

    ∗ ∗ ∗

    One

    Description: This dark is thick and oily. It fills the cracks in the floor first as it encroaches on the light. The thinner parts at its edges have a rainbow sheen like slicked water. It is cool (but not cold) to the touch. Once it has surrounded you and your torch, it will submerge you from the bottom up. It makes you feel like you need to hold your breath, as if you just dived into a pool.
    Properties: This dark cannot mix with water. Spilling water will slow it down, a misty spray or fog will halt it until the mist dissipates. Holy water will cause it to recede and can be used to create a path through the dark.

    Two

    Description: A misty black fog that smells like a putrid, deathly miasma. You feel a sense of impending doom in your chest when you breathe it in. It gets thicker, reducing your range of vision until you can no longer see the torch you're holding.
    Properties: This dark has a chance of infecting you with a disease, and can be dispelled by magic which cures disease.

    Three

    Description: Your shadow dances as the torchlight flickers but something is wrong. You almost didn't notice. Instead of stretching outward across the floor and against the walls like your compatriots' shadows, yours reaches toward the torchbearer. You feel as though your own shadow is mocking you. It grasps with a dim hand to smother the flame.
    Properties: Though this shadow defies your control, it is still your shadow. It cannot stretch out longer than a few times your own height, so keeping distance from your party's torchbearer will thwart its plans to grasp the torch. You can also crouch or go prone to shorten the shadow. Moving another light source to the opposite side of the light it's attempting to reach will turn it into a regular shadow of that opposing light - the dark can then attempt to possess a different person's or object's shadow.

    Four

    Description: Dark emanates as if from a black sun, leaving lit un-shadows where people and objects block its path. The source of the un-light is visible as a deep darkness that hurts the eye as your pupils dilate to take it in.
    Properties: Standing in direct un-light for too long can cause searing-cold burns to the skin. You can simply block the un-light, but much as throwing a cloth on a fire would cause it to burn, attempting to cover the source with a cloth would freeze it to the point of brittleness.

    Five

    Description: A dark, flickering flame emits the warmth of a hearth, but does not consume the matter on which it burns. Those lit by the flame will feel no pain - instead they will feel at home and no longer be compelled to move. They will stand comfortably in place until they can stand no longer, slipping into a comfortable sleep. The flame burns until their body rots. The flame is predatory - it burns a person's soul and keeps the soul from passing over until there is no physical body left to hold the flame.
    Properties: The black flame spreads across organic (living or dead) matter but does not burn it. Water will not put this flame out, but a regular flame will. Yes, this means setting your friend on fire. Each round the black flame deals damage to a character's Personality (in DCC; in other games, use the nearest thing to "willpower") and when it reaches zero that character loses all will. Instead of a DC 10 Reflex save, a DC 15 Willpower save is required to "stop drop and roll" the flame out.
    It doesn't take much imagination to see how this flame might be useful to necromancers and disastrous to forests.

    Six

    Description: When you light your torch to stave off the shadows, you notice it takes longer than normal. Not to light the torch or feel the heat of the flame. It takes longer for the light. The flame burns for a few seconds before the light hits the walls and floor. Your shadow struggles to catch up to you. Curious, you snuff out your torch. This time it takes a moment for the light to leave. As you attempt to relight your torch, a sense of dread enters you. It's taking much longer this time. Let's not test it further. 
    Properties: Any changes in lighting conditions take 1 Round to take effect. Each round, there is a 1-in-6 chance a torch inside this dark goes out and must be relit. For each light that goes out within or near this dark, both the number of Rounds delay and the chance in 6 go up by 1.
    The maximum speed you can move through this dark without overtaking your own light is 30' initially and goes down by 5' with each light it consumes.
    Note: The math almost certainly doesn't check out on the movement speed and it gets squirrely when considering different radii of light and move speeds. It's just intended to be usable and feel "wrong" - let's not start calculating redshift at the gaming table.

    More to come.

    Wednesday, July 9, 2025

    Elder Scrolls Flavoured Birth Augurs

    The Warrior

    Birth augurs are a neat idea. They help give each character a little more uniqueness. In the end they're just a simple numerical modifier but they can really shape a character by shining a spotlight on a particular trait. They have the right flavour for a Luck-based bonus too - we all have little superstitions about people having luck in certain areas of their life but not others. Some characters feel destined for a certain class just because of their birth augur.

    What's even better is the player in my campaign who chose to play a Thief with a negative to all Thief skills. I love that. Despite Luck being totally against him, he has chosen his own destiny. That alone has made him a fun character to play with.

    The thing that I find lacking with birth augurs, however, is any consistent theme or cohesion. I can't even tell what they're supposed to be. They come across as something like zodiac signs and yet they clearly aren't - one of them is "Lucky Sign" which more explicitly calls out a star sign but another is "survived a spider bite". I'm not the only one who has raised an eyebrow at that. 1 in 30 people have been bitten by a spider and that's the most interesting thing about their luck?

    That's not even an augur of one's birth!

    I get the feeling that the designers intentionally veered away from being specific here. Defining a bunch of star signs would have implications about the cosmology and the setting, which DCC intentionally leaves blank. Unfortunately the result is a table that has very little flavour and feels uninspired. In much the same way DCC encourages creating custom Mercurial Magic tables to flavour magic to different kinds of Wizards, custom Birth Augur tables can give some flair to your world and its cosmology. At the very least, you can do more with it than the original.

    The Inspiration (Morrowind and Oblivion)

    The Mage (interestingly the file is named "The Wizard")

    Videogames were my main pastime growing up, and if I recall correctly Morrowind was the game that taught me to use the keyboard and a mouse simultaneously. It's no surprise then that the Elder Scrolls series has had a massive influence on my taste in RPGs, both digital and analog. Oblivion I didn't play until much later, but it kept the same system.

    During character creation you are asked to choose a star sign from a list. From a mechanical standpoint you're just choosing a perk, but the existence of the star signs has implications for the world and your character is immediately tied to the world. This has deep personal implications for a character, likely influencing their path through life via the grand direction of the cosmos.

    That sounds kinda like a Birth Augur.

    The Lore (The Firmament)

    The Thief

    The real reason I'm doing this is because the lore of the constellations in The Elder Scrolls is weird and cool. Things that are weird and cool should be stolen entirely used as inspiration.

    There are thirteen starsigns. If you played Skyrim, you'll know them as the Standing Stones, which are just the same thing further gamified.

    Three of them are the Warrior, Mage and Thief. These guys clearly come from the big three archetypes in RPGs and that cements this trio as a real concept within the world rather than just a game mechanic. They're known as the Guardians.

    Each of them has three constellations as their Charges.

    The thirteenth constellation is the Serpent, who wanders the sky unpredictably. The Serpent is usually threatening one of the Charges, and the Guardians' job is to defend them. Those born under the Serpent are "the most blessed and the most cursed".

    The very sky itself is alive and in conflict. It has personalities within it, those personalities are meaningful to both the world and the game, and it affects characters both mechanically and in-universe. There is a fair bit more to the cosmology and it's also implied that the phases of the two moons affect these, but the game simply lists these 13 options to choose from and that's more than enough for us to make something cool out of it. 

    ∗ ∗ ∗

    The Table

    Roll a d12 and d14. The d12 represents the season of your birth, and the d14 represents the Serpent's activity during the season. If you roll doubles, the Serpent was threatening your constellation at the time of your birth and you take the relevant Serpent augur instead.

    d12 Birthsign Standard Augur Serpent Augur
    1 The Warrior Melee attack rolls Melee damage rolls
    2 The Lady Wil. saves Armor Class
    3 The Steed Speed Initiative
    4 The Lord Fort. saves Hit Points
    5 The Mage Corruption rolls Spell damage
    6 The Apprentice Number of languages Spell checks
    7 The Atronach* Spell checks x2, negative corruption Spell damage x2, negative corruption
    8 The Ritual Turn unholy checks Magical healing
    9 The Thief Ref. Saves Thief skills
    10 The Lover Personality checks with hirelings Critical hits
    11 The Shadow Sneak and hide checks Backstabs
    12 The Tower Find secret doors, find traps Lockpick, disable traps

    *The Atronach starsign has double the effect on spell checks (or damage, if Serpent) but a negative effect on corruption rolls. This is to thematically suit the Atronach as it exists in the Elder Scrolls games: great power at a cost.

    ∗ ∗ ∗

    All the effects on here were either taken directly from the DCC core book or this awesome extended Birth Augur table, with one obvious exception. There are less results than the original table and it isn't evenly distributed because you need to roll doubles to get the Serpent augurs. The probabilities of this might actually be a problem - you'll get even more doubles, which still happens often with a d30. The Serpent results are designed to feel more significant, as "those born under the serpent are more blessed and more cursed". Whether it's a blessing or curse obviously depends on your Luck modifier.

    If we wanted to go crazy with this we could potentially double the number of signs by creating variations depending on the moon phases as Morrowind implies - one for each with the "Prime Aspect of Masser" or "Prime Aspect of Secunda".

    The Takeaway

    Custom Birth Augur tables can inform what kinds of individuals exist in your world and how they tie in to the cosmos. The Elder Scrolls' magic is vastly different in flavour to DCC's magic, and that shines through when looking at the differences between DCC's Birth Augur table and Elder Scrolls' birthsigns. Notably there isn't a clear Cleric archetype because magical healing is basically a wizarding school, so there were no Cleric-focused signs to port directly over.

    This got me thinking about creating custom Birth Augur tables per setting, just the same way someone might create custom Occupation tables to better suit what kinds of people are expected to come out of character generation, or Mercurial tables for certain kinds of Wizards. It's easy and it's fun.

    I wonder about taking this a step further down the cosmic route and tying Augurs in with Alignments...

    Wednesday, July 2, 2025

    Mighty Deeds for non-Mighty Folk

    Mighty Deeds, as per the book, allow a Warrior to blind, disarm, pushback, trip, rally, and make defensive maneuvers and precise shots. Well, they allow a Warrior to basically attempt anything they want as part of an attack action, but these are the ones defined (suggested) by the book.

    The question seems to come up often though: what if a non-Warrior wants to trip or pushback an opponent? This isn't something you need special powers to be able to do. You can trip or push someone easily in real life, if you like (this is not legal advice). There are two common answers to this question and I think one of those is the obvious correct answer.

    One answer frequently given is that you do not let other characters attempt these actions, because they are the specialty of the Warrior. I think we can all agree Mighty Deeds are what makes Warriors in DCC awesome. They're the reason to pick Warrior over other classes. We don't want to take away what makes them special, or there's no longer a reason to pick Warriors, which in turn means there are no Warriors because nobody wants to be one. The thing is, Mighty Deeds aren't really about pushing or tripping - they encompass everything a Warrior could attempt as part of their attack action! To restrict non-Warriors from attempting these actions means to restrict them from doing anything other than hit or cast. That is obviously silly, I can't imagine saying "you can't trip people over because you're a Thief".

    The other frequently suggested option is that PCs are still allowed to use their action dice to perform skill checks, so just do that instead. They could, for instance, attempt a contested Strength check to pushback or a contested Agility check to trip. Some checks may be done trained or untrained. They just can't do it as a Mighty Deed using a Deed Die (which also gives greater odds and varying degrees of success compared to flat skill checks). This is a huge tradeoff when compared directly to a Warrior, who gets to simultaneously attack and basically attempt a whole other action for free. It keeps the game open and means the Judge doesn't have to step in and say no to entirely reasonable actions, while maintaining the awesomeness of Mighty Deeds.

    There is no action that can be a Mighty Deed that can't simply be treated as a different kind of action - the Mighty Deed is just a bonus opportunity to do an extra action as part of an attack. The Warrior can hit the demon and shove it back into the portal; the Cleric can shove the demon through the portal, but not while he's busy attacking or casting. The Wizard can swing from the chandelier, but it takes an Agility check, which costs him a chance to cast Fireball.

    Codifying this as a rule:

    Anything a Warrior could do with a Deed Die result of 3+, any other character can attempt as a DC 15 check. Each point higher the Deed result required, the DC increases by 3. This action is not an attack and thus does not deal damage - attempting something like "Blinding Attack" can achieve the blinding effect but not deal damage.

    This requires significant adjudication (especially if players are being creative instead of using listed Deeds), but then so do Mighty Deeds in the first place. Really all this rule is doing is drawing a rough parallel between DC and Deed Die results. DC 15 is "a feat of derring-do" and some of the example Mighty Deed results at 3, 4 and 5 seem like they should be achievable with some luck. Beyond that it becomes very hard or even impossible without moving up the dice chain, making these the domain of true Mighty Deeds by true Warriors.

    Gonzo versus Kitchen Sink

    In which I pretend I can define terms that are older than I am, in a niche I haven't been part of for that long. ∗ ∗ ∗ The terms "g...